|
|
Post by Kyungran on May 7, 2016 22:50:42 GMT 10
I already picked myself, Sunggyu, and Kyunghoon.
I was hoping to keep the game moving along, but it looks like it's not going to happen tonight so I should have waited after all.
|
|
|
|
Post by Ahyoung on May 7, 2016 22:50:47 GMT 10
Although the fact that you're trying hard to make Kyungran trust you gives me hope that she's actually a citizen too  |
|
|
|
Post by Sunggyu on May 7, 2016 22:51:46 GMT 10
I have to agree. I do not know who the criminal was out of Eynji Nuna and Ahyoung Nuna. And I do not know with any certainty of Hongchul Hyung's guilt or innocence. But being the third round, I think there is more at play here than people playing for their teams. It is clear that Hongchul at least, is not playing for his team but for Ahyoung. Now, I hope he is a criminal in that case, because being one citizen down due to misplaced obligations will make this very difficult.
And I agree with Eunji Nuna. If he had used garnets to find out for sure, he could not have said with 100% certainty without disqualifying himself and his team.
|
|
|
|
Post by Ahyoung on May 7, 2016 23:00:38 GMT 10
I have to agree. I do not know who the criminal was out of Eynji Nuna and Ahyoung Nuna. And I do not know with any certainty of Hongchul Hyung's guilt or innocence. But being the third round, I think there is more at play here than people playing for their teams. It is clear that Hongchul at least, is not playing for his team but for Ahyoung. Now, I hope he is a criminal in that case, because being one citizen down due to misplaced obligations will make this very difficult. And I agree with Eunji Nuna. If he had used garnets to find out for sure, he could not have said with 100% certainty without disqualifying himself and his team. You say you're not sure who is a criminal between me and Eunji, yet then say Hongchul isn't playing for his team but mine, and that citizens are down one if he's bad. If you're not sure if I'm bad, why aren't you considering we really are just on the same team as citizens? And since you believe that Hongchul is playing for me, you should believe that I would have told him if I were a criminal. YOU are just trying to protect your criminal buddy, Eunji. And Kyungran, please know that I would have told Hongchul Again, he never said I'm 100% a citizen! He phrased it differently. Did he check? No idea. But I don't think what he said would disqualify him. And I'm feeling more confident that the team of criminals is Eunji, Jinho and Sunggyu now. |
|
Eunji
Eliminated
Posts: 986 
|
Post by Eunji on May 7, 2016 23:02:48 GMT 10
I have to agree. I do not know who the criminal was out of Eynji Nuna and Ahyoung Nuna. And I do not know with any certainty of Hongchul Hyung's guilt or innocence. But being the third round, I think there is more at play here than people playing for their teams. It is clear that Hongchul at least, is not playing for his team but for Ahyoung. Now, I hope he is a criminal in that case, because being one citizen down due to misplaced obligations will make this very difficult. And I agree with Eunji Nuna. If he had used garnets to find out for sure, he could not have said with 100% certainty without disqualifying himself and his team. You say you're not sure who is a criminal between me and Eunji, yet then say Hongchul isn't playing for his team but mine, and that citizens are down one if he's bad. If you're not sure if I'm bad, why aren't you considering we really are just on the same team as citizens? And since you believe that Hongchul is playing for me, you should believe that I would have told him if I were a criminal. YOU are just trying to protect your criminal buddy, Eunji. And Kyungran, please know that I would have told Hongchul Again, he never said I'm 100% a citizen! He phrased it differently. Did he check? No idea. But I don't think what he said would disqualify him. And I'm feeling more confident that the team of criminals is Eunji, Jinho and Sunggyu now. Although the fact that you're trying hard to make Kyungran trust you gives me hope that she's actually a citizen too X |
|
|
|
Post by Ahyoung on May 7, 2016 23:06:07 GMT 10
You say you're not sure who is a criminal between me and Eunji, yet then say Hongchul isn't playing for his team but mine, and that citizens are down one if he's bad. If you're not sure if I'm bad, why aren't you considering we really are just on the same team as citizens? And since you believe that Hongchul is playing for me, you should believe that I would have told him if I were a criminal. YOU are just trying to protect your criminal buddy, Eunji. And Kyungran, please know that I would have told Hongchul Again, he never said I'm 100% a citizen! He phrased it differently. Did he check? No idea. But I don't think what he said would disqualify him. And I'm feeling more confident that the team of criminals is Eunji, Jinho and Sunggyu now. Although the fact that you're trying hard to make Kyungran trust you gives me hope that she's actually a citizen too X I only am because you've now convinced me that she's a citizen  If not, then well done on fooling me! |
|
|
|
Post by Ahyoung on May 7, 2016 23:11:18 GMT 10
Kyunghoon I'm guessing you're the fourth citizen, so I'm begging you to please reject this team if you haven't already. I don't know what to say to convince you I'm good, but please look over all my actions and consider whether they strike you as criminal or citizen. I think they'll show you I'm good.
|
|
Eunji
Eliminated
Posts: 986
|
Post by Eunji on May 7, 2016 23:15:26 GMT 10
 now who is desperately pandering to people she knows to be citizens? Why are you so sure Jinho is a criminal? |
|
|
|
Post by Sunggyu on May 7, 2016 23:20:13 GMT 10
I don't actually understand what Ahyoung has just said. I will try to go back and understand it.
|
|
|
|
Post by Ahyoung on May 7, 2016 23:20:19 GMT 10
now who is desperately pandering to people she knows to be citizens? Why are you so sure Jinho is a criminal? Yeah, I am desperate not to lose, I've never claimed otherwise You're a point up on me right now so you can be a little less desperate, but I need to do what I can to turn this around. Did I ever say I'm sure Jinho is a criminal? I don't believe I did. It's merely a hunch, of course |
|
|
|
Post by Kyunghoon on May 7, 2016 23:21:49 GMT 10
Im backreading now...so the jury is me, kyungran, and hongchul? Im so confused right nw i dont know if ah young or eunji are innocent...but there is a way to find out
|
|
|
|
Post by Ahyoung on May 7, 2016 23:23:22 GMT 10
Im backreading now...so the jury is me, kyungran, and hongchul? Im so confused right nw i dont know if ah young or eunji are innocent...but there is a way to find out There sure is, Kyunghoon  |
|
Eunji
Eliminated
Posts: 986
|
Post by Eunji on May 7, 2016 23:24:28 GMT 10
Im backreading now...so the jury is me, kyungran, and hongchul? Im so confused right nw i dont know if ah young or eunji are innocent...but there is a way to find out You, Kyungran and Sunggyu. And there sure is |
|
Eunji
Eliminated
Posts: 986
|
Post by Eunji on May 7, 2016 23:25:23 GMT 10
snap, Ahyoung! |
|
|
|
Post by Bandage Man on May 7, 2016 23:26:55 GMT 10
It's been requested I clarify the rules regarding purchasing information and what is/isn't allowed to be said.
Ahyoung is correct in that Hongchul's phrasing made it a bit of a grey area, but the rules are that you aren't allowed to claim 100% knowledge of anyone's role. This is of course to keep the integrity of the game as designed intact without it turning into a game of who believes who's claim of information. However when it comes to someone without information claiming information this also leads to problems as it can lead to assertations that someone knows for a fact they haven't bought information since they're "allowed" to say that.
So, all that being said, no rules have been broken but overall you are not allowed to claim absolute knowledge of anyone's role. Hongchul's statement is fine albeit treading a little too close to the line, hence this situation. So to be clear, no claiming 100% anything. You cannot make statements of being certain towards someone's role, or to believing them, or anything that hints as such.
Carry on.
|
|
